| Massachusetts Institute of Technology | Arts Across the Curriculum | 03/15/12 | $1,500,000 | Cambridge, MA, United States | Higher Learning |
| Southwestern University | Transforming Paideia: Integrative, and Intentional Learning | 03/15/12 | $500,000 | Georgetown, TX, United States | Higher Learning |
| Colby College | Senior President: Student Writing | 03/15/12 | $250,000 | Waterville, ME, United States | Higher Learning |
| Southwestern University | Senior President: Business and the Liberal Arts and Library and Information Services | 03/15/12 | $250,000 | Georgetown, TX, United States | Higher Learning |
| Dartmouth College | Mellon Mays Undergraduate Fellowship Program - 2012 Renewal | 03/15/12 | $247,500 | Hanover, NH, United States | Higher Learning |
| Colgate University | Technology in Teaching the Liberal Arts | 12/17/12 | $50,600 | Hamilton, NY, United States | Higher Learning |
| Union College | Shared Humanities | 01/22/13 | $50,000 | Schenectady, NY, United States | Higher Learning |
| Brown University | New Directions Fellowships [Cammett] | 03/14/13 | $260,000 | Providence, RI, United States | Higher Learning |
| Haverford College | New Directions Fellowships [Zadeh] | 03/14/13 | $235,000 | Haverford, PA, United States | Higher Learning |
| University of Virginia | New Directions Fellowships [Loeffler] | 03/14/13 | $256,300 | Charlottesville, VA, United States | Higher Learning |
| Johns Hopkins University | Arts on Campus | 03/14/13 | $1,200,000 | Baltimore, MD, United States | Higher Learning |
| University of New Mexico | Pedagogy Innovation | 03/14/13 | $250,000 | Albuquerque, NM, United States | Higher Learning |
| University of Wisconsin at Madison | Public Humanities | 03/14/13 | $1,100,000 | Madison, WI, United States | Higher Learning |
| Washington College | SANDBOX | 03/14/13 | $575,000 | Chestertown, MD, United States | Higher Learning |
| United Negro College Fund, Inc. | UNCF/Mellon Mays Undergraduate Fellowship Program | 03/14/13 | $3,406,350 | Washington, DC, United States | Higher Learning |
| The New School | Curriculum Planning | 12/16/13 | $35,000 | New York, NY, United States | Higher Learning |
| Amherst College | New Directions Fellowships [Katsaros] | 03/13/14 | $262,500 | Amherst, MA, United States | Higher Learning |
| Princeton University | New Directions Fellowships [Holmes] | 03/13/14 | $292,400 | Princeton, NJ, United States | Higher Learning |
| University of Massachusetts at Amherst | New Directions Fellowships [Atalay] | 03/13/14 | $206,500 | Amherst, MA, United States | Higher Learning |
| University of California at Davis | Research Initiatives in the Humanities: Phase II | 03/13/14 | $1,725,000 | Davis, CA, United States | Higher Learning |
| American Historical Association | Multiple Careers for Historians | 03/13/14 | $1,600,000 | Washington, DC, United States | Higher Learning |
| Middlebury College | Galvanizing Digital Liberal Arts | 03/13/14 | $800,000 | Middlebury, VT, United States | Higher Learning |
| Skidmore College | Project VIS - Enhancing Visual Communication and Understanding Through Creative Pedagogy and Integrative Learning | 03/13/14 | $750,000 | Saratoga Springs, NY, United States | Higher Learning |
| Lawrence University | Lawrence-Ripon Collaboration Planning | 12/15/14 | $100,000 | Appleton, WI, United States | Higher Learning |
| University of Chicago | Undergraduate Student Support System | 02/23/15 | $110,000 | Chicago, IL, United States | Higher Learning |
